Skip to content

Public Domain page: Confusing structure #1422

Description

@Chealer

The Public Domain page just changed and is now much richer, but also more complex. It is now non-trivial to understand its structure. Whereas the previous version only had 2 sections, “CC0” and “Public Domain Mark”, the new one keeps these (as “CC0” and “Public Domain Dedication”), but among several more.

After about a minute, I understood the structure, but I first had to use the page inspector to confirm that “CC0” was a header.

Some things which are contributing to the confusion:

  1. The very narrow width stretches headers over a long (tall) space.
  2. The rare/“original” positioning of labels (“badges”), causing an unusual alignment of these 2 headers (shifted to the right by the floating labels)
  3. The links on these 2 headers, making them even more unusual
  4. The absence of a table of contents
  5. The self-link on “Public Domain Dedication”
  6. The use of the title “Public Domain Dedication” about the PDM

I suppose there are several ways to mitigate/solve that, but I would particularly recommend:

  1. At least 1 of:
    1. Adding a ToC
    2. Making sections extendable/collapsible
    3. Making the distinction between a subsection and its parent clear, either by increasing indentation or adding a border
  2. Renaming “Public Domain Dedication” to “Public Domain Mark” or defining “Public Domain Dedication”
  3. Not linking to itself. I am guessing the current target is a bug, and rather supposed to link to information/material about the PDM.
  4. At least 1 of:
    1. Floating the labels to the right
    2. Moving the labels after the headers rather than before

By the way, each image of the 2 sections is in its figure element. It's not clear to me which role these 2 elements play (as containers), but they are invalid (due to the id attribute).

🅭🄍

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    Projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions