Repository navigation
Swift 6: Main actor-isolated property 'listener' cannot be used to satisfy nonisolated protocol requirement with RIBs 0.9.2 #43
Description
Activity
I am currently investigating this and working on a proper solution.
I'm still in research mode so my current conclusions might change later but the intent is to mark everything in the framework that supposed to be main thread related, such as the presenter protocol, as
@MainActorto force the main thread isolation. Potentially this will also applies to theViewableRouter/ViewableRoutingas well. Everything else should be markednonisolatedas actions on those objects can happen on the main thread or a background thread (especially in the case of headless RIBs with no UI). But this is my current understanding and perhaps I'm missing something.This is related to #6 as fixing and setting the right swift concurrency isolation scopes will most likely help with future addition of async/await support.
I have some progress on this already and will try to have a proof of concept working next week. But, currently I'm facing some swift compiler limitations that might force a breaking change, which I want to avoid, on the users of RIBs framework. Specifically with marking certain things like
var listener: PresentableListener? { get set }inprotocol MyRIBPresentable: Presentabledeclarations asnonisolatedexplicitly. This potentially would be a minor change though, comparing to more widespread marking ofnonisolatedor@MainActoracross codebases. That is what I'm trying to avoid by carefully settingnonisolated/@MainActoron the parent types that the users of the framework subclass from or adopt.Reacted by jeong jin ho@jeongjinho here's a working prototype that solves this issue: #45
Moving the conversation there.
When generating a new RIB using the RIBs template (version 0.9.2) under Swift 6, I encounter the following compiler error:
Main actor-isolated property 'listener' cannot be used to satisfy nonisolated protocol requirementThis happens because the generated code marks the listener property as
@MainActor, but the corresponding protocol requirement is nonisolated.Steps to Reproduce
1. Create a new RIB module using the RIBs template on version 0.9.2.
2. Build the project in Xcode with Swift 6 enabled.
3. Observe the compiler error above.
Expected Behavior
Generated RIB code should compile successfully under Swift 6 without actor isolation mismatches.
Actual Behavior
Compilation fails due to mismatch between
@MainActorisolated property and nonisolated protocol requirement.Environment
• RIBs version: 0.9.2
• Swift version: 6.0
Is there a recommended way to update the generated RIBs code (or RIBs framework itself) so that the listener property works correctly with Swift 6’s stricter actor isolation rules?
Should protocol definitions also be annotated with
@MainActor, or is there an official workaround planned?